48 participants read sentences word by word, such as Der Lehrer, der den Schüler gesehen hat, lachte laut über den Witz (subject relative) and Der Lehrer, den der Schüler gesehen hat, ... (object relative). Object relatives slow readers down at the end of the relative clause and on the main verb. 24 items, two counterbalanced lists, 12 words per sentence.
Format
A tibble with 13824 rows and 8 columns:
- participant
Participant ID,
P01toP48.- list
Counterbalancing list, 1 or 2.
- item
Item ID,
i01toi24.- condition
"subject"or"object"relative clause.- position
Word position in the sentence, 1 to 12.
- region
Role of the word in the sentence, with levels in sentence order: determiner (
"det") and noun of the main clause, relative pronoun, then determiner, noun, participle and auxiliary of the relative clause ("rc_det"to"rc_auxiliary"), main verb, three spillover words and the final word.levels(german_relatives$region)gives the codes.- length
Word length in letters.
- rt
Reading time in ms.
Details
True model:
The object-relative cost is 0.01
to 0.03 in the relative clause, 0.04 on the participle, 0.05 on the
auxiliary and the main verb and 0.02 on the next word, with
by-participant variation (SD 0.03). By-participant intercepts p0 have
SD 0.2 and by-item intercepts i0 SD 0.04; residual SD 0.2. The cost
on the auxiliary matches the neutral condition of Schriefers,
Friederici and Kühn (1995, Experiment 1: 1350 against 1424 ms). Their
relative clauses were ambiguous until the auxiliary and had no main
clause verb after them, so the cost on the other words and all data
are simulated.
References
Schriefers, H., Friederici, A. D. & Kühn, K. (1995). The processing of locally ambiguous relative clauses in German. Journal of Memory and Language, 34(4), 499-520. doi:10.1006/jmla.1995.1023
Examples
round(tapply(german_relatives$rt, german_relatives[c("region", "condition")], mean))
#> condition
#> region subject object
#> det 349 353
#> noun 362 359
#> rel_pronoun 344 354
#> rc_det 344 351
#> rc_noun 356 363
#> rc_participle 354 368
#> rc_auxiliary 332 355
#> main_verb 345 368
#> spillover_1 340 354
#> spillover_2 341 336
#> spillover_3 340 335
#> final 338 341
if (requireNamespace("lme4", quietly = TRUE)) {
mv <- subset(german_relatives, region == "main_verb")
m <- lme4::lmer(log(rt) ~ condition + (1 | participant) + (1 | item), data = mv)
lme4::fixef(m)
}
#> (Intercept) conditionobject
#> 5.8027047 0.0651166
