Skip to contents

Use of do (Did he go?, He did not go) in 300 texts dated 1400 to 1575, in four sentence types: the number of clauses with do out of all eligible clauses. In negative declaratives, negative questions and affirmative questions the change follows S-curves with the same slope and different starting points (the Constant Rate Effect). Do stays rare in affirmative declaratives, which rise more slowly.

Usage

do_support

Format

A tibble with 1200 rows and 5 columns:

text

Text ID, T001 to T300.

year

Year of the text.

context

"affirmative declarative", "negative declarative", "affirmative question" or "negative question".

do

Clauses with do.

eligible

All clauses in this context in this text.

Source

data-raw/do_support.R

Details

True model, in log-odds: intercept + slope * (year - 1350) / 100, plus by-text intercepts (SD 0.4). The slope is 3.7 per century in the three rising contexts and 2.82 in affirmative declaratives. The intercepts at 1350 are -8.33 (negative declaratives), -5.57 (negative questions), -6.58 (affirmative questions) and -8.32 (affirmative declaratives). These are Kroch's (1989, Tables 4 and 9) estimates from Ellegård's counts for 1400 to 1575; the affirmative questions are his transitive adverbial and yes/no questions. After 1575 the contexts diverge and do in affirmative declaratives declines, so the simulation stops at 1575. Texts and counts are simulated.

References

Ellegård, A. (1953). The auxiliary do: The establishment and regulation of its use in English. Stockholm: Almqvist & Wiksell.

Kroch, A. S. (1989). Reflexes of grammar in patterns of language change. Language Variation and Change, 1(3), 199-244. doi:10.1017/S0954394500000168

Examples

do_support$century <- (do_support$year - 1350) / 100
m <- glm(cbind(do, eligible - do) ~ 0 + context + context:century, data = do_support,
         family = binomial)
round(coef(m), 2)
#>         contextaffirmative declarative            contextnegative declarative 
#>                                  -7.85                                  -8.45 
#>            contextaffirmative question               contextnegative question 
#>                                  -6.56                                  -5.72 
#> contextaffirmative declarative:century    contextnegative declarative:century 
#>                                   2.65                                   3.81 
#>    contextaffirmative question:century       contextnegative question:century 
#>                                   3.70                                   3.81 
rising <- subset(do_support, context != "affirmative declarative")
anova(glm(cbind(do, eligible - do) ~ context + century, data = rising, family = binomial),
      glm(cbind(do, eligible - do) ~ context * century, data = rising, family = binomial),
      test = "Chisq")
#> Analysis of Deviance Table
#> 
#> Model 1: cbind(do, eligible - do) ~ context + century
#> Model 2: cbind(do, eligible - do) ~ context * century
#>   Resid. Df Resid. Dev Df Deviance Pr(>Chi)
#> 1       896     993.88                     
#> 2       894     993.45  2   0.4232   0.8093