Use of do (Did he go?, He did not go) in 300 texts dated 1400 to 1575, in four sentence types: the number of clauses with do out of all eligible clauses. In negative declaratives, negative questions and affirmative questions the change follows S-curves with the same slope and different starting points (the Constant Rate Effect). Do stays rare in affirmative declaratives, which rise more slowly.
Format
A tibble with 1200 rows and 5 columns:
- text
Text ID,
T001toT300.- year
Year of the text.
- context
"affirmative declarative","negative declarative","affirmative question"or"negative question".- do
Clauses with do.
- eligible
All clauses in this context in this text.
Details
True model, in log-odds: intercept + slope * (year - 1350) / 100, plus by-text intercepts (SD 0.4). The slope is 3.7 per century in
the three rising contexts and 2.82 in affirmative declaratives. The
intercepts at 1350 are -8.33 (negative declaratives), -5.57 (negative
questions), -6.58 (affirmative questions) and -8.32 (affirmative
declaratives). These are Kroch's (1989, Tables 4 and 9) estimates from
Ellegård's counts for 1400 to 1575; the affirmative questions are his
transitive adverbial and yes/no questions. After 1575 the contexts
diverge and do in affirmative declaratives declines, so the
simulation stops at 1575. Texts and counts are simulated.
References
Ellegård, A. (1953). The auxiliary do: The establishment and regulation of its use in English. Stockholm: Almqvist & Wiksell.
Kroch, A. S. (1989). Reflexes of grammar in patterns of language change. Language Variation and Change, 1(3), 199-244. doi:10.1017/S0954394500000168
Examples
do_support$century <- (do_support$year - 1350) / 100
m <- glm(cbind(do, eligible - do) ~ 0 + context + context:century, data = do_support,
family = binomial)
round(coef(m), 2)
#> contextaffirmative declarative contextnegative declarative
#> -7.85 -8.45
#> contextaffirmative question contextnegative question
#> -6.56 -5.72
#> contextaffirmative declarative:century contextnegative declarative:century
#> 2.65 3.81
#> contextaffirmative question:century contextnegative question:century
#> 3.70 3.81
rising <- subset(do_support, context != "affirmative declarative")
anova(glm(cbind(do, eligible - do) ~ context + century, data = rising, family = binomial),
glm(cbind(do, eligible - do) ~ context * century, data = rising, family = binomial),
test = "Chisq")
#> Analysis of Deviance Table
#>
#> Model 1: cbind(do, eligible - do) ~ context + century
#> Model 2: cbind(do, eligible - do) ~ context * century
#> Resid. Df Resid. Dev Df Deviance Pr(>Chi)
#> 1 896 993.88
#> 2 894 993.45 2 0.4232 0.8093
