
Picture naming before and after therapy for word-finding difficulties
Source:R/data.R
aphasia_naming.Rd16 people with chronic aphasia name 120 pictures each, twice before and once after eight weeks of cueing therapy. Half of each person's items were practised in therapy and half were not. Naming of treated items improves for almost every participant, and the two baselines do not differ. Naming of untreated items improves only for the five participants with a phonological profile: relatively good semantic processing and impaired phonological output. For mixed logistic regression of repeated measures, three-way interactions and generalisation in therapy studies.
Format
A tibble with 5760 rows and 6 columns:
- participant
Participant ID,
P01toP16.- profile
"other"or"phonological".- item
Picture, numbered within participant (
P01_001).- set
"untreated"or"treated".- session
"baseline 1","baseline 2"or"post-therapy".- correct
1 if the picture was named correctly, 0 if not.
Details
True model: the logit of a correct response is
p0 + i0 + post * gain. Participant intercepts p0 have mean -0.45 (SD 0.9) and item
effects i0 SD 1.2. For treated items, gain is the participant's
own gain (mean 1, SD 0.35). For untreated items it is 0.7 in the
phonological profile and 0.05 otherwise, plus noise (SD 0.1). The design
follows Best et al. (2013). In their 16 participants, naming of treated
items rose from 43.5 to 62% correct, and only participants with
relatively good semantic and impaired phonological processing
generalised to untreated items. The number of items, the size of the
subgroup and all data are simulated.
References
Best, W., Greenwood, A., Grassly, J., Herbert, R., Hickin, J. & Howard, D. (2013). Aphasia rehabilitation: Does generalisation from anomia therapy occur and is it predictable? A case series study. Cortex, 49(9), 2345-2357. doi:10.1016/j.cortex.2013.01.005
Examples
round(tapply(aphasia_naming$correct, aphasia_naming[c("set", "session")], mean), 2)
#> session
#> set baseline 1 baseline 2 post-therapy
#> untreated 0.40 0.42 0.46
#> treated 0.44 0.44 0.64
round(tapply(aphasia_naming$correct,
aphasia_naming[c("profile", "set", "session")], mean), 2)
#> , , session = baseline 1
#>
#> set
#> profile untreated treated
#> other 0.41 0.47
#> phonological 0.39 0.38
#>
#> , , session = baseline 2
#>
#> set
#> profile untreated treated
#> other 0.43 0.47
#> phonological 0.38 0.38
#>
#> , , session = post-therapy
#>
#> set
#> profile untreated treated
#> other 0.43 0.66
#> phonological 0.53 0.58
#>
p01 <- subset(aphasia_naming, participant == "P01" & set == "treated" &
session != "baseline 1")
mcnemar.test(table(before = p01$correct[p01$session == "baseline 2"],
after = p01$correct[p01$session == "post-therapy"]))
#>
#> McNemar's Chi-squared test with continuity correction
#>
#> data: table(before = p01$correct[p01$session == "baseline 2"], after = p01$correct[p01$session == "post-therapy"])
#> McNemar's chi-squared = 14.815, df = 1, p-value = 0.0001186
#>
# \donttest{
if (requireNamespace("lme4", quietly = TRUE)) {
d <- subset(aphasia_naming, session != "baseline 1")
m <- lme4::glmer(correct ~ session * set * profile + (1 | participant) + (1 | item),
data = d, family = binomial,
control = lme4::glmerControl(optimizer = "bobyqa"))
round(lme4::fixef(m), 2)
}
#> (Intercept)
#> -0.34
#> sessionpost-therapy
#> -0.03
#> settreated
#> 0.20
#> profilephonological
#> -0.29
#> sessionpost-therapy:settreated
#> 1.01
#> sessionpost-therapy:profilephonological
#> 0.82
#> settreated:profilephonological
#> -0.18
#> sessionpost-therapy:settreated:profilephonological
#> -0.75
# }