Reading measures on the verb in sentences like The key to the cabinet(s) was/were rusty: grammaticality by number of the attractor noun. A plural attractor makes ungrammatical were easier to read. 40 participants read 32 items, each in one condition (four counterbalanced lists).
Format
A tibble with 1280 rows and 10 columns:
- participant
Participant ID,
P01toP40.- list
Counterbalancing list, 1 to 4.
- item
Item ID,
i01toi32.- grammaticality
"grammatical"or"ungrammatical".- attractor
Number of the attractor noun,
"singular"or"plural".- skipped
1 if the verb was skipped in first-pass reading.
- first_fixation
Duration of the first fixation on the verb in ms;
NAif skipped.- gaze_duration
Sum of first-pass fixations in ms;
NAif skipped.- regression
1 if the reader made a regression out of the verb in first pass;
NAif skipped.- total_time
Sum of all fixations on the verb in ms;
NAif never fixated.
Details
True model:
log(gaze_duration) = 5.55 + 0.14 * ungrammatical
- 0.09 * ungrammatical * plural
logit(regression) = -1.9 + 0.9 * ungrammatical
- 0.5 * ungrammatical * pluralGaze durations have by-participant (SD 0.15) and by-item (SD 0.08)
intercepts and residual SD 0.3. Regressions out of the verb in first pass
have a by-participant SD of 0.5. Skipping rate about 14%, unrelated to condition.
The first fixation equals the gaze duration in 65% of trials and is 50
to 85% of it otherwise. Total time adds a rereading time (log-normal,
median about 220 ms) with probability plogis(-1 + 0.6 * ungrammatical + 1.5 * regression). The sentences follow Bock and
Miller (1991), who found attraction errors in production. In reading, a
plural attractor reduces the disruption caused by an ungrammatical verb
(Wagers, Lau and Phillips 2009). The effect sizes and data are
simulated.
References
Bock, K. & Miller, C. A. (1991). Broken agreement. Cognitive Psychology, 23(1), 45-93. doi:10.1016/0010-0285(91)90003-7
Wagers, M. W., Lau, E. F. & Phillips, C. (2009). Agreement attraction in comprehension: Representations and processes. Journal of Memory and Language, 61(2), 206-237. doi:10.1016/j.jml.2009.04.002
Examples
aggregate(gaze_duration ~ grammaticality + attractor, data = agreement_attraction,
FUN = mean)
#> grammaticality attractor gaze_duration
#> 1 grammatical singular 271.5694
#> 2 ungrammatical singular 306.6347
#> 3 grammatical plural 276.6960
#> 4 ungrammatical plural 286.7132
mean(agreement_attraction$skipped)
#> [1] 0.1429688
if (requireNamespace("lme4", quietly = TRUE)) {
m <- lme4::lmer(log(gaze_duration) ~ grammaticality * attractor + (1 | participant) +
(1 | item), data = agreement_attraction)
lme4::fixef(m)
}
#> (Intercept)
#> 5.55015633
#> grammaticalityungrammatical
#> 0.11821301
#> attractorplural
#> 0.01384567
#> grammaticalityungrammatical:attractorplural
#> -0.08109389
